You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (2024)

The weather is getting colder by the day which means we’re looking for warming, comfort foods to get us through until Christmas.

And, while we all love a roast dinner, it’s not do-able every day.

You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (1)

Enter: the perfect stew.

Stews are great for this time of year as they fill you up, can be hearty when filled with root veg and can be made in a slow cooker.

If you love stew, but find yours turns out mushy, too wet or chewy then we have the solution.

What's your favourite winter dish? Let us know in the comments below...

You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (2)

Daily Star Online spoke to top chefs to find out where we’re going wrong, plus their number one tips, for mind-blowing winter stew.

Ligia Lugo, culinary expert, recipe developer and co-founder of The Daring Kitchen, explained the biggest mistakes we make when it comes to hearty stews:

Using any and every cut of meat.

This is one of the biggest mistakes you can make when making beef stew.

A marbled ribeye might be appealing, but tender steaks are wasted by a slow simmer or braise.

If you try to braise a ribeye all of that fat will be lost, leaving you with dry beef that you wouldn’t want to eat.

You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (3)

Filet mignon is too lean and won’t benefit from the slow cooking required of a stew.

Your go-to options are heartier, tougher cuts of beef like chuck roast (the front shoulder) or round roast (from the rear).

They are tough and chewy if you cook them quickly, but if you simmer them the collagen and fat will melt and tenderise the protein.

Another plus is that they are cheaper than the prized cuts.

Throwing the beef in raw

To add a savoury flavour to your stew you should always sear your meat before the braising process.

Brown the cubed meat in batches so you don't overcrowd the pot and steam the meat instead of browning it.

It will caramelise on the outside without cooking through.

That caramelisation adds extra depth and umami (savouriness) to the stew which is otherwise lost if you just throw the meat in raw.

Throwing all ingredients at the same time

Don’t just throw everything in the pot and hope it turns out delicious.

The meat used in the stew needs to cook way longer to become tender than the veggies.

If you put them in at the same time the carrots, potatoes and peas will turn to mush by the time the meat is ready.

You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (5)

Add the chopped hearty veggies about 45 minutes before the meat is done cooking, this will allow for enough time to cook until tender without making them into mush.

If you plan on adding more delicate veggies like peas wait until a few minutes before taking the stew off the heat.

Not using wine

Cooking the meat in wine enhances the stew. All that braised goodness can be a bit heavy.

Use some wine, vinegar or even lemon juice to lighten and brighten it up.

Braising the meat in water

Yes, a stew means meat braised in liquid but no one said that the main liquid should be water.

Beef or veal stock and beef broth are all great choices to add extra flavour to the stew.

Other options include vegetable and mushroom stock and basically anything but fish stock.

Don’t serve the stew solo.

Polenta, thick-cut baguette or egg noodles are an ideal companion.

You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (6)

Don't use thickeners.

Yes, stew is heartier than soup but that comes from the fact that the pieces of meat and veggies are bigger than in an ordinary soup.

The potatoes will contribute the starch that the stew needs and make it thick enough.

James Cochran, head chef 12:51 and Around the Cluck, and Great British Menu winner, added his top tips:

The slower the better

I would say 85 degrees Celcius for eight hours is required – cook it overnight to wake up to a house smelling of meat.

Add a table spoon of marmite

The yeast extract gives the dish richness whilst cooking.

Marinade the meat 24hrs prior to cooking

I like to use red wine with an array of spices.

Nutmeg, clove and cinnamon work well and are perfect flavours for this time of year.

You've been cooking beef stew wrong – chefs explain their warming recipes (2024)

FAQs

What do you think would have gone wrong with the stew preparation? ›

Here are the most common mistakes when making a stew - and how to avoid them
  1. Not searing meat. Many people turn to a stew after a long day as it is an easy one-pot meal. ...
  2. Not simmering long enough. The best stews are the once that are slow-cooked. ...
  3. Adding herbs too early. ...
  4. Let your stew rest. ...
  5. Season, season, season.
Oct 23, 2023

What not to put in beef stew? ›

But the liquid itself should not be thick in the same way that gravy is thick. So skip the roux, and don't bother dusting the meat with flour or cornstarch before browning, either, as some recipes will suggest. That will just interfere with getting a good sear on the meat, and gum up the stew with unneeded starch.

What is the heat method of stewing? ›

Stewing is a moist heat, slow cooking method, where small uniform pieces of meat and/or vegetables are cooked in liquid, and then served in the resulting gravy.

Why can't you boil a stew? ›

First of all, you want to simmer a stew, not boil one. Boiling a stew will cause the liquid to evaporate at a very high rate. Your stew will likely dry out before the meat becomes tender, so back off on the heat. Having to add more liquid while the stew is cooking will weaken the flavor of the finished product.

Can you mess up beef stew? ›

Not cooking it enough

Stew is a dish that needs a good amount of cooking time. If you're in a hurry, forget it. The meat must be cooked over heat for at least two hours to allow the meat fibers to break down so the it will be tender enough in the stew.

What happens if you cook stew too long? ›

Don't Stew the Stew Too Long Either

It might seem that cooking your beef stew on low for 8 hours will make it even better, but that is not true at all. Your beef will be tough if you don't cook it enough and it will be tough if you cook it too much. It's just science, take it from us!

What gives beef stew the best flavor? ›

Add spices such as turmeric, coriander and cumin at the early stage of cooking, when you are frying onions and garlic, to enhance the taste of the beef stew. Fresh herbs like coriander and bay leaves also contribute a distinct flavour without making the dish too spicy for the younger members of the family.

What to add to beef stew to make it amazing? ›

Vegetables: small chopped carrots, celery, and onion or shallot practically melt into the sauce. Mushrooms: button mushrooms are a nod to the quartered mushrooms many classic beef stew recipes call for, but are thinly sliced instead of being left in bigger pieces. Garlic: minced garlic brings lots of cozy flavor.

What can I add to my beef stew to make it tastier? ›

Add the wine and tomato paste to the onions and other aromatics in a pan before slow cooking. Plus, this helps to really deglaze any fond that's left. This ingredient is one that your mum and nan would probably use in their stews. It adds a bit of tang, sweetness and savoury spices that give an extra punch of flavour.

How do you reduce the heat in stew? ›

Turns out, the fiery chemical in hot chilis, capsaicin, likes to bind itself onto a compound in milk, which neutralizes the burn. Add a generous dollop of sour cream, creme fraiche, or yogurt to scorching hot chili or stews, or even a touch of milk or cream.

What is the rule for stewing? ›

Use Low Heat

Low heat is suggested for all stews, never a hard boil. Placing a lid, slightly ajar on the pot traps the escaping steam and allows it to condense and fall back onto the stew. You can also cook stews in a 350°F oven or on low in a slow cooker.

What are the 5 steps of stewing? ›

How to cook a basic stew
  1. Chop the ingredients. Cutting the meat and/or main vegetables to roughly the same size will help them to cook evenly.
  2. Fry your base ingredients. ...
  3. Add the remaining ingredients. ...
  4. Add your liquid of choice. ...
  5. Let it simmer. ...
  6. Season to taste.
Nov 16, 2018

Why put tomato paste in beef stew? ›

A bit of tomato paste amps up the flavor of beef stew, giving it a richness and a punch of umami that makes the stew truly memorable.

Why is my beef chewy in stew? ›

Not cooking the stew long enough.

Chuck meat is your best bet for beef stew, but it's also a pretty tough cut so it needs time to break down and become tender. Rush the cooking process and the beef will be tough and chewy. Follow this tip: For really tender meat, cook the stew low and slow, for approximately two hours.

Why add vinegar to beef stew? ›

The addition of the vinegar adds subtle acidity that balances well with the soy sauce and the honey giving this otherwise super hearty beef stew a nice lightness to it.

How does stewing cooking method affect food? ›

Stewing – Method

Compared to boiling, stewing preserves more of the nutrients and flavour of the food. Additionally, this particular cooking method requires a smaller amount of fat than frying. The difference between stewing and steaming is that when steaming, the food does not come into contact with the water.

What is the effect of stewing? ›

Long-term stewing increased the fat content of porcine subcutaneous fat. Increasing the ratio of linoleic to stearic acids enhanced the softness of fat. The location × stewing time interaction significantly affected PUFA and texture.

What effect does stewing have on meat? ›

Tender Meat: The slow cooking process breaks down tough cuts of meat, making them tender and juicy. Nutrient Retention: The moist cooking method helps retain the nutrients in the ingredients, especially in vegetables, compared to methods such as boiling or stir-frying.

Why is stew tough? ›

Not cooking the stew long enough.

Chuck meat is your best bet for beef stew, but it's also a pretty tough cut so it needs time to break down and become tender. Rush the cooking process and the beef will be tough and chewy. Follow this tip: For really tender meat, cook the stew low and slow, for approximately two hours.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Last Updated:

Views: 5829

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Birthday: 1992-08-21

Address: Apt. 237 662 Haag Mills, East Verenaport, MO 57071-5493

Phone: +331850833384

Job: District Real-Estate Architect

Hobby: Skateboarding, Taxidermy, Air sports, Painting, Knife making, Letterboxing, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Saturnina Altenwerth DVM, I am a witty, perfect, combative, beautiful, determined, fancy, determined person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.